Catch 24 Elmont Inc.


 Reviews

Contact and Address

Address
City
State
Postal Code
Country
Phone
Email
Website

Opening Hours

Monday
Tuesday
Wednesday
Thursday
Friday
Saturday
Sunday

Map and Directions

Photos

6 Reviews on “Catch 24 Elmont Inc.”

Excellent
4.8
6 reviews
5
4
3
2
1
  • Tom S

    Absolutely wonderful dinner date experience here the other night.

    We started with happy hour and got some fresh raw oysters. The price was right for the oysters, and the taste and freshness were even better than the price. We grabbed 2 local NY oysters and my favorite, the bar harbor blonde from Maine. They had such a great selection of oysters. I was impressed.

    The drink selection was very good. Plenty of bottled and craft beers. Huge wine list and great cocktails.

    For starters, duck spring rolls and the biscuits. The spring rolls had a ton of tender duck in a crispy shell with a sweet orange sauce. The biscuit was buttery and had a cheesy flavor.

    For mains, we split the dry aged duck and the scallops. The duck was ultra tender. Not really crispy. Sweet but tangy orange sauce. And the creamy yam puree went great with the tender yam slices. The scallops were larger in size but there were only 3. The sear on them was good and paired well with the pancetta and tiny Brussel sprouts.

    Highly recommended for a nice dinner or date night.

  • Tom S

    Absolutely wonderful dinner date experience here the other night.

    We started with happy hour and got some fresh raw oysters. The price was right for the oysters, and the taste and freshness were even better than the price. We grabbed 2 local NY oysters and my favorite, the bar harbor blonde from Maine. They had such a great selection of oysters. I was impressed.

    The drink selection was very good. Plenty of bottled and craft beers. Huge wine list and great cocktails.

    For starters, duck spring rolls and the biscuits. The spring rolls had a ton of tender duck in a crispy shell with a sweet orange sauce. The biscuit was buttery and had a cheesy flavor.

    For mains, we split the dry aged duck and the scallops. The duck was ultra tender. Not really crispy. Sweet but tangy orange sauce. And the creamy yam puree went great with the tender yam slices. The scallops were larger in size but there were only 3. The sear on them was good and paired well with the pancetta and tiny Brussel sprouts.

    Highly recommended for a nice dinner or date night.

  • Steve Melnyk

    Came here for Valentines Day and couldn’t have been any happier. This is our go-to spot to stop in for fresh oysters and wine. Reservations are a must, and the food is always consistent and just at another level. Great spot in Bay Shore

  • Joe Badolato

    Went for the first time and will now be my new place for brunch. The chef (Ryan) made me the best duck hash I ever had to date.

  • Michael

    Very cool place. Cocktails were great quality. We ordered some oysters too since they were on happy hour. Also great! Definitely would like to come again and try some more items from the food menu.

  • Jacqueline Byrne

    Me and my boyfriend love this place. Food and drinks are always delicious, and definitely can’t skip dessert here! Have always had the best experience sitting with Emily, she alone makes it worth the trip. Always super attentive, and has the best positive energy.

Leave a Review

Select a rating