Reviews
Contact and Address
| Address | |
| City | |
| State | |
| Postal Code | |
| Country | |
| Phone | |
| Website |
Opening Hours
| Monday | |
| Tuesday | |
| Wednesday | |
| Thursday | |
| Friday | |
| Saturday | |
| Sunday |
Map and Directions
Photos
The Old Mill Inn
Contact and Address
| Address | |
| City | |
| State | |
| Postal Code | |
| Country | |
| Phone | |
| Website |
Opening Hours
| Monday | |
| Tuesday | |
| Wednesday | |
| Thursday | |
| Friday | |
| Saturday | |
| Sunday |
Map and Directions
Photos
5 Reviews on “The Old Mill Inn”
It’s been a few days since we’ve been to The Old Mill Inn, and I’m still thinking about the wings. They were excellent! The menu had a great variety of food and the restaurant itself has cool, what we call “I Spy” items on the wall and on shelves. There’s also a pool table and arcade upstairs. With Alfred State and University close by, The Old Mill Inn is definitely a great place to eat.
Great wings, beer, and pizza. Super friendly servers and great service.
Mediocre AT BEST. The “cook” shows little regard for customer requests and doesn’t care about the quality of his food served. Plating is sloppy. Keep in mind, this is all simple pub and not difficult to make! The first half a dozen visits i ordered wings, which are jumbo, straight from the menu, and they were always under cooked, one time so badly. I sent them back. One would think this impossible, as they precook them. Afterward, I have ordered wings extra crispy, xx-crispy, and xxx-crispy. They were mostly cooked inside, but still not crispy enough, except for the xxx, which were like jerky. They also do a poor job at skimming the fryers before cooking the wings, as there are always bits and pieces of grease soaked fries mixed in. They also just dump the sauced wings on the plate extra pool of sauce included at No charge, which is unbelievable, as the only give 1 blue cheese free, even when you order a double or triple order of wings, but will happily add more, without asking, for $.75 a piece. They also do the same with their salad dressing, even if you order a large, “dinner sized,” and not side salad. On the salads, there is ALWAYS rotten lettuce included, free of charge. Burgers are almost always not the correct doneness, over or under, almost like they don’t own an instant read thermometer. The pizza is almost always decent.
Wings and hand cut fries were delicious tonight. Definitely will be back
Had a wonderful first visit and looking forward to more. They cook my wings exactly how I asked . Thank you for going above and beyond.