Sag Harbor Tavern


 Reviews

Contact and Address

Address
City
State
Postal Code
Country
Phone
Email
Website

Opening Hours

Monday
Tuesday
Wednesday
Thursday
Friday
Saturday
Sunday

Map and Directions

Photos

5 Reviews on “Sag Harbor Tavern”

Excellent
5
5 reviews
5
4
3
2
1
  • Music Love

    Just amazing all around, perfect for a nice dinner or you may sit at the bar and enjoy a game. The food, staff, service and drinks were perfect . Definitely recommend 💕

  • Barbeque Chef

    Craft Kitchen & Tap House, Huntington

    I found myself near Huntington today, and decided to knock off another Hamburger on my Hit List.

    As I found a parking spot very close to Craft, that ended up being my choice today, out of the few others in Huntington I also want to try.

    I was pleased with my choice, as I had seen on their online menu that Craft used hamburger meat from a well known NYC butcher, Pat La Frieda.

    I have eaten LaFrieda hamburger meat numerous times in the past. Shake Shake uses them, and the vaunted Minetta Tavern uses them, as do many other restaurants in NYC.

    Most restaurants order a custom blend of meats from LaFrieda. Their blends range all over the map from 2 meat blends, to 5 meat blends, with various combinations.

    The blend that Craft uses is called the Signature blend, according to the menu.

    They had a few burgers on the menu to choose from.

    I ordered the Blue Devil Buger, with tater tots on the side..

    I ordered the burger my usual medium rare, and now, I always ask that the bun is toasted.

    It came out near perfect, temperature wise.

    The bun to meat ratio was very good.

    I have no idea what blend of different cuts of meats they used in it..It was very mild in taste,though.
    It tasted very good.

    The French Fries were great, as they were definitely cut in house, and done the proper way. They had that very prominent potato forward taste to them.

    Tater Tots were real good, as well

    As I mentioned, they use a LaFrieda blend of meat, and I liked it.

    The mild taste of the meat just didn’t do it for me, as far as exciting my taste buns. I need Earthy, Salty, and unctuous meat to have a burger make it into my “Best of”, “Top Tier” Universe, and list.

    I will reiterate, the burger was good, just not my Top Tier taste.

    Their menu is quite large, and covers a lot of bases.The drink, and cocktail menus were also quite extensive.

    The service was very good. Tanya, the bartender, was polite, prompt,and professional

    She also made a fantastic Old Fashioned for me to wash down my burger. It had everything I liked about an Old Fashioned, Large ice cube, Luxardo Cherries, Orange peel, bitters, and my favorite, Demerara Simple syrup.

    They have Bourbon Flights there🥰, as well some other liquor Flights, which will bring me back here another day.

    It wasn’t busy at lunch, when I arrived there, maybe 6 people at the big bar they have, and only 1 table of people in the restaurant area.The fireplace was lit, in the rear of the restaurant, which was a nice touch.. It’s a big beautiful place.

    I paid cash, but there is a 3.75% vig added for credit card use

    Old Fashioned was reasonably priced at $13

    Burger, with cheese, bacon, fried onions , n tater tots, $19. I think that’s a good value, with all the extras that come with the burger.

    It’s directly across the street from the Paramount, so it fills up fast when shows are there.

    In fact, some of the band members from the band playing this evening were there eating lunch. Super nice guys.

    Parking..I got lucky that I found a place right out front.There are a few lots around town to handle the parking situation in the Village, but as everyone knows, on weekends, it can be a nightmare to park there. They have no problems handing out parking tickets in the Village.

    2/14/24

  • J Kev.

    Went here yesterday w/ my husband to have some drinks & apps before seeing a show at the Paramount across the street. We sat at the bar. The nachos made w/ homemade potato chips & shredded chicken were very good! I must say that Mike, the bartender was excellent. He attended to our every need. I didn’t need to try to get his attention. He was looking around the entire time trying to see if anyone needed anything. We might come back here because it seems like this place knows how to run a great restaurant.

  • Andrea Chronister

    First time here. Visiting from out of town, fantastic food, service and atmosphere. Entertainer was excellent/ manager even came over to check if everything was great! Highly recommended!!! Boys got burgers, my daughter got steak tacos & I got fish tacos!! All excellent!

  • Weeble Wobble

    This is truly an amazing experience. I had a very attentive bartender. The spinach/artichoke dip was amazing. The draft beer (IPA) was super amazing. You can find heaven here. The decor and the sunlight veranda ambience makes it super sensual and enjoyable.

Leave a Review

Select a rating